Campaign domain reputation: what Postmaster Tools, SNDS and Sender Hub show.
Google Postmaster Tools, Microsoft SNDS and Yahoo Sender Hub show how mailbox providers assess your sending: spam reports, authentication, delivery errors and filter results, but only for mail to their own mailboxes, such as personal Gmail, Outlook.com and Yahoo accounts. In a B2B campaign to business mailboxes, there tends to be little of this data, or none at all. In that case, bounces, replies, tests on your own mailboxes and DMARC reports tell you about domain reputation.
- Published
- Updated
- Reading time
- 8 min
- Category
- Deliverability
- Author
- DYNTRO team
What is domain reputation and who assesses it?
Reputation is a mailbox provider's assessment of a sender, built on the sender's sending history. In the Postmaster Tools documentation, Google describes it as an assessment of the quality of the domains and IP addresses that mail is sent from, depending on how they are used for sending. The higher the reputation, the better the chance that a message lands in the inbox rather than in spam.
There is no shared score. Google, Microsoft and Yahoo assess a sender separately, each based on the mail it receives itself, and each shows senders different data: Google and Yahoo mainly per domain, Microsoft in SNDS per IP address. Domain data appears only for authenticated mail. Postmaster Tools attributes messages to the domain from the DKIM signature or from SPF, and Yahoo to the DKIM domain. We describe how to set up these records in the article on SPF, DKIM and DMARC.
What does Google Postmaster Tools show?
Postmaster Tools shows data on mail sent to personal Gmail accounts, i.e. addresses in the gmail.com and googlemail.com domains. Google states explicitly that the data covers only such messages. You add the DKIM signing domain (d=) or the SPF domain from the Return-Path address to the tool, and verify ownership with a TXT or CNAME record in DNS. Without verification, the tool shows no data.
The current version of Postmaster Tools, released in 2024, has dashboards for:
- compliance with Gmail's requirements: SPF and DKIM, DNS records, message format, encryption and the spam report rate, and for bulk senders also DMARC and unsubscribe;
- spam rate, i.e. messages marked as spam by recipients;
- feedback loop for campaigns tagged with an identifier;
- authentication, i.e. the share of mail that passes SPF, DKIM and DMARC;
- encryption, i.e. the share of mail sent over TLS;
- delivery errors, i.e. the share of messages rejected or temporarily deferred, with the reasons.
The old interface still has domain and IP reputation dashboards on a scale of bad, low, medium and high. Google has announced that they will be retired and replaced with a new dashboard, and has postponed the retirement of the old interface without giving a new date.
The spam rate needs careful reading. Google calculates it only from DKIM-authenticated messages that reached the inbox and that the recipient marked as spam themselves. A very low figure may therefore mean that Gmail itself is routing a large part of the mail to spam, so recipients have nothing to report. Since 1 February 2024, Gmail's guidelines have required this rate to be below 0.3%, and they recommend keeping it below 0.1%.
The data is not live; it usually refreshes within 24 hours. On days with low sending volume it may be missing, because this is how Google protects user privacy. Google does not state a volume threshold.
What does Microsoft SNDS show?
SNDS (Smart Network Data Services) is a Microsoft tool that a sender uses to check their reputation at Outlook.com. Unlike Postmaster Tools, it shows data for IP addresses, not for domains. Access to the data is granted to whoever can show that they are responsible for the given IP address range.
For each IP address, SNDS shows, among other things:
- the number of RCPT and DATA commands and the number of recipients;
- the filter result in colours: green when spam is less than 10% of the mail from the address, yellow at 10-90% and red above 90%;
- the recipient complaint rate.
Microsoft notes that there may be no data for addresses that sent fewer than 100 messages on a given day. For a campaign, however, something else matters more. When sending goes through an IP address shared with other senders, SNDS shows all complaints about that address, regardless of the sender's domain. The result then says something about the server and everyone who sends from it, not about the campaign domain. When campaign mailboxes run with an email provider, the IP addresses belong to the provider, and it is the provider that can show it is responsible for them.
What does Yahoo Sender Hub show?
Sender Hub is Yahoo's site for senders, with requirements, error codes and services. From a reputation point of view, what matters are the Complaint Feedback Loop and Insights.
The Complaint Feedback Loop sends the sender a report when a recipient marks a message as spam. It works only for DKIM-signed mail and for a domain the sender has added and verified.
Insights, available since October 2025, show the number of delivered messages and the spam complaint rate for a verified DKIM domain, compared with the previous period. Data appears 24-48 hours after the feature is switched on, and only if the domain exceeds a minimum daily volume. Yahoo calculates the complaint rate only from messages delivered to the inbox, so the result may differ from the sender's own calculation, which also counts mail filtered to spam.
What will these tools not show in a campaign to business mailboxes?
Each of these tools shows mail to the mailboxes that the given provider hosts: personal Gmail accounts, Outlook.com and Yahoo domains. A B2B campaign, however, goes mainly to addresses on company domains. A company may use Google Workspace for email, but a message to its address will not appear in Postmaster Tools data, because Google counts only personal Gmail accounts there.
Then there is volume. A B2B campaign usually sends few messages a day, and even fewer to personal mailboxes. Google and Yahoo may show no data at low volume, and Microsoft at fewer than 100 messages a day from an IP address. An empty dashboard therefore does not mean that everything is fine. It means there is no measurement.
Even complete data will not tell you which folder of a business mailbox a message landed in, whether a filter set by the company's administrator stopped it, or whether anyone read it.
Which signals remain?
- Bounces. Rejections with x.7.x codes and a series of 4.7.x codes, especially at one provider, are often the first sign of a problem with reputation or with authentication. We describe how to read them in the article on email bounces.
- Replies. A drop in replies with the same content and a similar segment may mean that messages are going to spam. Replies such as “where did you get my address?” and unsubscribe requests show that some recipients may also be clicking “Report spam”.
- Tests. You send the same message from the same mailbox to your own test mailboxes at several providers, including Google Workspace and Microsoft 365, and check where it landed and what the Authentication-Results header says. Details are in the article on why emails go to spam.
- DMARC reports. Business mail systems also send aggregate reports. Microsoft 365 sends them to domains with a valid address in the rua tag if the recipient company's mail goes directly to Microsoft 365. The report shows authentication results, not reputation, but it also covers business addresses.
How often should you check campaign domain reputation?
It is worth doing once a week and before every increase in volume. Once a week, because the data refreshes with a delay: in Postmaster Tools usually within 24 hours, while changes in the compliance dashboard can take up to 7 days to appear. Yahoo Insights also compares data with the previous period. Before increasing volume, because Google recommends increasing sending gradually and monitoring delivery in Postmaster Tools as you do so.
The weekly review is best recorded in one table with the same set of signals. That way you see the change from week to week rather than a single result.
Example company and data, campaign domain example.com.
| Signal | Result this week | Conclusion |
|---|---|---|
| Postmaster Tools | no data, few messages to Gmail accounts | no measurement, so not a sign that all is well |
| Yahoo Insights | no data | no measurement |
| SNDS | email provider's IP addresses, no access | signal unavailable |
| Bounces | a few 5.1.1 codes from one batch of the contact list, no 5.7.x codes | check this batch before the next send |
| Replies | a similar number to the week before | no change |
| Test on own mailboxes | inbox in Gmail and Microsoft 365, SPF, DKIM and DMARC “pass” | volume can go up by another step |
Summary.
- Postmaster Tools shows domain data, but only for mail to personal Gmail accounts and only with sufficient sending volume.
- SNDS shows IP address data. With a shared server, it tells you about the server, not about the campaign domain.
- Yahoo Sender Hub shows complaints and deliveries for a verified DKIM domain.
- In a campaign to business mailboxes, these tools are often empty. No data means no measurement.
- What remains are bounces, replies, tests on your own mailboxes and DMARC reports, checked once a week and before increasing volume.
We run email and LinkedIn campaigns to decision-makers, from data and domains to replies, while your salespeople focus only on conversations. See the service: B2B email campaigns.
Book a callQuestions and answers.
Why does Google Postmaster Tools show no data for my domain?
Most often because the data covers only mail to personal Gmail accounts, while a B2B campaign goes mainly to company addresses. Data may also be missing at low volume, and without domain verification in DNS the tool shows none at all. An empty dashboard does not mean that everything is fine. It means there is no measurement.
How do you check domain reputation in a campaign to business mailboxes?
Through signals from the campaign itself: bounces, replies, tests on your own mailboxes and DMARC reports. You send a test message from the same mailbox to your own test mailboxes at several providers, including Google Workspace and Microsoft 365, and check where it landed. It is worth doing once a week and before every increase in volume.
Sources.
- Google, Set up Postmaster Toolssupport.google.com
- Google, Postmaster Tools dashboardssupport.google.com
- Google, Learn about the deprecation of the old Postmaster Tools interfacesupport.google.com
- Google, Email sender guidelinessupport.google.com
- Microsoft, Smart Network Data Services (SNDS)substrate.office.com
- Microsoft, SNDS FAQsubstrate.office.com
- Yahoo Sender Hubsenders.yahooinc.com
- Yahoo Sender Hub, Complaint Feedback Loopsenders.yahooinc.com
- Postmaster @ Yahoo, Introducing Insights: A New Way to Understand Your Delivery Performanceblog.postmaster.yahooinc.com
- Microsoft Learn, Set up DMARC to validate email in Microsoft 365learn.microsoft.com
