A separate domain for cold email: why the campaign is not sent from the company domain.
A separate domain for cold email keeps the campaign apart from company email: mailbox providers also judge the sender by its domain, and Gmail counts messages from subdomains together with the primary domain, so sending from a subdomain is counted together with company email. That is why we run campaigns on separate domains, which we configure and warm up before sending, and the recipient sees who is writing from the first email.
- Published
- Updated
- Reading time
- 5 min
- Category
- Deliverability
- Author
- DYNTRO team
How do mailbox providers assess the sender?
Email filters assess not only the content of a message but also who sends it. In its Sender Best Common Practices document, M3AAWG writes that the reputation attached to a domain or subdomain can be an important part of filtering, alongside message content and IP address reputation.
Google shows this in Postmaster Tools. There, reputation is an assessment of the quality of the domains and IP addresses that email comes from, based on their sending behaviour. The domain reputation dashboard has four levels: high, medium, low and bad. With a bad reputation, almost all email from the domain goes to spam or is rejected. The dashboard shows messages sent from exactly the domain that was used for DKIM and SPF authentication. This dashboard is in the old Postmaster Tools interface. Google has announced that it will not be in the new version and that a new dashboard will replace the reputation dashboard. It has postponed the retirement of the old interface and has not given a new date.
What does Gmail count together with the primary domain?
Gmail has separate requirements for bulk senders. According to the FAQ for Google's sender guidelines, a bulk sender is one that sends close to 5,000 or more messages to personal Gmail accounts within 24 hours. For this threshold, Gmail counts all messages from the same primary domain together. In Google's example, 2,500 messages from the primary domain and 2,500 from its promotional subdomain together make a bulk sender. This status is permanent and does not expire when the way of sending changes.
The compliance dashboard in Postmaster Tools works in a similar way. It shows the status only for the primary domain, but also uses data from its subdomains for the assessment. The domain reputation dashboard shows a subdomain separately, but the bulk sender threshold and the compliance status are counted for the whole primary domain.
In practice, this means that a campaign sent from a company subdomain counts towards the company's primary domain. It can therefore change that domain's status in Gmail, and a problem with the campaign can affect company email, which carries proposals, invoices and salespeople's correspondence. A campaign on a separate domain counts towards a different primary domain.
A subdomain or a separate domain?
For a campaign, a separate domain: sending does not count towards the company domain, and the company's everyday email stays out of the campaign.
| Issue | Subdomain of the company domain | Separate campaign domain |
|---|---|---|
| Bulk sender threshold in Gmail | messages count together with the primary domain | messages count towards a different primary domain |
| Compliance status in Postmaster Tools | subdomain data goes into the primary domain's assessment | separate assessment |
| Who is writing | the brand is visible in the address | it has to be shown in the signature and on the website under the domain |
Why do we run campaigns on separate domains?
At DYNTRO, we run cold email campaigns on separate domains. The client's company domain takes no part in sending, so the campaign does not count towards it in Gmail, and any problem with the campaign does not carry over to the company's everyday email.
We configure and warm up a new domain before the campaign, and the signature and the website under the campaign domain show the recipient straight away who is writing. We describe how this works in the service in the section on campaign domains.
How do you prepare a separate domain for cold email?
A separate campaign domain must be transparent. It must not impersonate another company or brand, and the recipient must see who is writing to them from the first email. In practice:
- a signature with the sender's first name and surname, the company name and its website address;
- a website under the campaign domain that redirects to the company's website with a valid HTTPS certificate; M3AAWG recommends that every domain in a message, when typed into a browser, should lead to the domain of the organisation sending the email or to a page about reporting abuse;
- A and MX records: according to M3AAWG, some receivers do not deliver email from a domain without a valid A record, and the domain in the sender's address should have an MX record;
- the same domain in the sender's address, the Return-Path (envelope sender) address and the DKIM signature; M3AAWG recommends a consistent domain throughout the message, and for DMARC it is sometimes required;
- SPF, DKIM and DMARC; Gmail requires all senders to have at least SPF or DKIM, and we describe how to set up all three in the article on SPF, DKIM and DMARC.
A new domain has no sending history, so the volume from it is increased gradually, and according to M3AAWG this also applies to a new subdomain.
An example company has its website and company email on the example.com domain and runs its campaign from the separate domain example.org. The people and addresses are examples, and example.com and example.org are domains reserved for examples.
| Element | What the recipient sees |
|---|---|
| Sender address | Anna Nowak, anna.nowak@example.org |
| Signature | Anna Nowak, example company, example.com |
| example.org typed into a browser | redirect to https://example.com with a valid certificate |
| Recipient's reply | goes to the anna.nowak@example.org mailbox, which someone reads |
Summary.
- Mailbox providers also assess the sender by its domain, and Postmaster Tools shows the reputation of the domain used for authentication.
- Gmail counts messages from subdomains together with the primary domain towards the bulk sender threshold, and this status is permanent.
- A separate domain keeps the campaign apart from company email, and a new domain is configured and warmed up before sending.
- A campaign domain must not impersonate anyone, and the recipient must see who is writing.
We run email and LinkedIn campaigns to decision-makers, from data and domains to replies, while your salespeople focus only on conversations. See the service: B2B email campaigns.
Book a callQuestions and answers.
Will the recipient see a different domain from the company one?
Yes. The sender's address is in the campaign domain, not in the company domain. That is why the message must state clearly who is writing: the signature includes the first name and surname, the company name and its website address, and the campaign domain typed into a browser leads to the company's website with a valid HTTPS certificate. The campaign domain must not impersonate any other company or brand.
Sources.
- Google, Email sender guidelines FAQsupport.google.com
- Google, Postmaster Tools dashboardssupport.google.com
- Google, Learn about the deprecation of the old Postmaster Tools interfacesupport.google.com
- M3AAWG Sender Best Common Practices, version 4.0m3aawg.org
- Google, Email sender guidelinessupport.google.com
