Cold email follow-up: how many messages, at what intervals and with what argument.
Cold email follow-up means at most three progressively shorter messages after the first email, making an email sequence of up to 4 messages, sent every few days in the same thread, with a new argument at each step. The last message closes the thread without pressure, and a reply from the recipient at any point stops the next steps.
- Published
- Updated
- Reading time
- 8 min
- Category
- Messages
- Author
- DYNTRO team
Why send a follow-up if someone has not replied?
No reply to the first message is rarely a decision. The recipient may have read it at a bad moment, put it off until later or missed it among the other emails that day. Some people only reply when the same topic comes back from a different angle.
So a follow-up has one job: to give the recipient a new reason to reply. It is not a reminder that a message is waiting, nor a request to confirm that they have read it. Sentences like “I just wanted to bump my message” or “Have you had a chance to look at my email?” add nothing. The recipient gets the same thing a second time, plus pressure to explain themselves.
How many messages should an email sequence have?
Up to 4 messages: the first and at most three follow-ups. That is enough to show the topic from several angles, and it does not turn the campaign into a series of reminders.
The number 4 is an upper limit, not a target. If you do not have another argument that really adds something, it is better to end the sequence after three messages than to add a step just to make up the number. Each additional email to someone who stays silent also increases the risk that instead of a reply you will get an unsubscribe request or a spam complaint.
Length matters too. At DYNTRO the first email is the longest and most substantial, because it has to present the reason for contact, the recipient's problem and the proof. Each later one is shorter, and the last one is the shortest. A follow-up does not repeat the first message, because the recipient has it in the same thread, just below the new one. We describe how to build the first message in the article on the first email in a B2B campaign.
At what intervals should you send the next messages?
Every few days. In DYNTRO campaigns, a few days pass between steps, e.g. 4-5, and the next email does not go out on the day after the previous one. Messages on consecutive days look like pressure, or like software that does not wait for a reply. A recipient who put the first email aside for later has not yet had time to come back to it.
Too long a gap is also harmful. After a few weeks the recipient no longer remembers the first message, and the follow-up would have to explain everything again. A few days is an interval at which the thread is still fresh and the recipient has had time to reply.
A simple rule helps when planning intervals: send only on business days, so a step that would fall on a Saturday moves to Monday.
Why does a follow-up go in the same thread?
A follow-up sent as a reply to the first message appears in the recipient's mailbox in the same thread as the first message. The recipient sees the whole history and does not have to search for what was said. This allows the new message to be short.
A thread is not the same as “Re:” in the subject line. RFC 5322, the Internet Message Format standard, describes how a reply uses the In-Reply-To and References header fields, which point to the message being replied to. The References field can also be used to identify the conversation thread. The same standard describes “Re:” at the start of the subject as a marker of a reply. A new message with “Re:” added by hand is therefore not a reply. The recipient gets a separate email that pretends to continue a conversation, and quickly notices.
That is why the later steps are sent as replies in the thread of the first message, without a new subject and without a manually added “Re:”. We say more about why a fake “Re:” does harm in the article on the subject line in a B2B campaign.
What should a cold email follow-up say so that it is not just a reminder?
Each step in the sequence has its own argument and its own call to action. The argument is another side of the same offer: a different effect for the company, a different situation from the recipient's work, a different piece of proof. The call to action changes too. If the first email asked whether the topic is relevant now, the second can ask for a short call, and the third whether to come back to the topic at another time.
This is how we write the later steps at DYNTRO. We do not repeat the recipient's name in every email, because the context is in the thread. The call to action asks whether the topic is relevant or asks for a conversation. It does not promise a complimentary analysis, a plan or material, because then the conversation starts with a gift rather than with the recipient's need.
An example company sells a system for planning service technicians' visits. The sequence goes to service directors at installation companies.
| Message | When | Argument | Call to action |
|---|---|---|---|
| first | launch day | the dispatcher builds the schedule by hand and corrects it with every change in service requests | whether visit planning is relevant right now |
| second | 4 days after the first | shorter journeys and more visits on the same day | a call next week |
| third | 5 days after the second | fewer calls from customers asking when the technician will arrive | whether to come back to the topic when planning for next year |
| last | 5 days after the third | no new argument, closing the thread | no question, a reply whenever the topic becomes relevant |
The next boxes show the messages after the first. Each goes as a reply in the thread of the first message, so it has no subject of its own.
- To
- service director, example installation company
Hello,
One more angle on visit planning. When the schedule is drawn up by software that knows the addresses of the service requests and the technicians' skills, journeys between visits are shorter. Technicians spend less time on the road, and more jobs fit into the same day.
Could you spare 20 minutes next week to talk about how this works at your company?
The second message does not go back to the schedule from the first. It focuses on a different effect of the same offer and asks for a call, not whether the topic is relevant.
- To
- service director, example installation company
Hello,
A quick note about customers. When a visit has a confirmed time window and the technician uses their phone to let people know about a delay, fewer people call the office to ask when someone will arrive.
Is this a topic worth coming back to when you plan for next year?
How do you write the last message?
The last message closes the thread. It brings no new argument and applies no pressure. It says that this is the end of the messages on the matter and leaves the recipient an easy way back: all they need to do is reply in the same thread.
Weak endings are pressure (“this is your last chance”), reproach (“I have not received any reply”) or a joke meant to force a reaction. Each of them leaves a worse impression than no last email at all. A calm close works the other way. A recipient for whom the topic becomes relevant in a few months has a thread in their inbox that they can return to without awkwardness.
- To
- service director, example installation company
Hello,
This is my last email on this. If visit planning becomes relevant, just reply in this thread.
When should you stop the sequence before the last step?
When the recipient replies. Any reply from a person stops further emails to that person, including a decline, an objection and “please get in touch next quarter”. An automatic follow-up after a reply looks as if nobody read it. In DYNTRO campaigns we read every reply, including those from a different address, and stop further emails to anyone who has replied, as we describe in the section on the daily campaign check.
The sequence is also stopped in other situations:
- an unsubscribe request ends contact in all of the sender's campaigns;
- a reply from a different address or from another person at the same company: the sequence tool may not recognise it, so further emails have to be stopped manually, and the content of the reply decides what happens with other people at that company;
- a hard bounce: the address drops out of the campaign, because later steps would bounce too.
An auto-reply does not stop the sequence: the next steps go out as planned.
Summary.
- A sequence has up to 4 messages: the first and at most three follow-ups. A step without a new argument is better left out.
- A few days pass between messages, e.g. 4-5, not one.
- A follow-up goes as a reply in the same thread, without a new subject and without a manually added “Re:”.
- Each later message is shorter and has a different argument and a different call to action.
- The last one closes the thread without pressure, and any reply stops the next steps.
We run email and LinkedIn campaigns to decision-makers, from data and domains to replies, while your salespeople focus only on conversations. See the service: B2B email campaigns.
Book a callQuestions and answers.
How many follow-ups should you send?
At most three after the first message, i.e. up to 4 messages in the sequence in total. Each follow-up should bring a new argument. If there is no third argument, it is better to end the sequence earlier than to add a step that only reminds the recipient of the previous ones.
What if the recipient only replies after the last message?
Such a reply counts just like any other. It is assessed by the same rules and answered in the same thread. The last message ends the sequence, not the conversation: it should leave the recipient an easy way back, even after several weeks.
Sources.
- RFC 5322, Internet Message Formatdatatracker.ietf.org
